Following a lengthy legal battle that I waged, the military censor was forced to approve a version of this article that reveals some details while leaving many others under wraps.

The project in question has been running for many years, has cost at least one billion shekels, and continues to drain public funds. It began as a covert operation in which corruption was uncovered. Senior defense officials believe the project serves no security purpose and should be shut down, but the Defense Ministry’s security directorate insists on keeping it going.

The Israeli defense establishment is running a unique project involving animals for security purposes, intended to enhance Israel’s defensive capabilities. The project’s very existence has until now been kept secret. It is being disclosed here for the first time, following a campaign I waged with the assistance of Adv. Elad Man.

Journalist Ran Adelist of Maariv was involved in an earlier stage of the campaign. Adelist was the first to learn of the story, many years ago. But neither he nor I had previously managed to penetrate the information-security barriers maintained by the Defense Ministry’s security directorate (Malmab), the military censor and other security agencies.

Approval for this exclusive publication, which represents a compromise, was granted by the Three-Member Committee, a quasi-judicial body chaired by former Supreme Court Justice Ayala Procaccia. Its other members are Brig. Gen. (res.) Itai Baron, representing the defense establishment, and Shalom Kital, representing the media. The committee serves as an appeals body for decisions made by the military censor.

It has since emerged that the animal project, which was operated by former members of an elite IDF unit specially trained for the task, was born out of serious allegations of corruption raised by some of its earliest participants.

Over the years, the project proved to have had almost no operational impact. Nevertheless, more than one billion shekels were squandered on maintaining it, feeding the animals, veterinary care, training the personnel and purchasing specialized equipment. Despite this enormous waste of public money, no one in the defense establishment - including successive generations of senior commanders- had the courage to order its closure. Instead, the defense establishment imposed a sweeping blackout on the project’s very existence and activities.

The decision to establish the project and deploy animals was part of an effort to upgrade the defense establishment’s capabilities, along the lines of similar programs operated by top major militaries around the world.

When the proposal was first raised many years ago, the defense minister at the time rejected it, arguing that the defense establishment was not a “zoo.” But after he left office, the idea was revived. The plan was initiated by a combat soldier from an elite unit who was business partners with a senior defense official. The official later left the defense establishment to pursue business interests, before returning to serve in select positions in several of its agencies.

"H., one of the first people involved in the venture: Instead of investigating the suspicions of corruption, they investigated us and falsely accused us"

"H., one of the first people involved in the venture: Instead of investigating the suspicions of corruption, they investigated us and falsely accused us"

The people behind the unusual animal-based security project believed it was of considerable importance to Israel’s security. They operated using covert methods and cover stories, that were common at the time among agencies within the defense establishment.

It should be emphasized that, since the establishment of the state, Israel’s defense establishment has purchased, deployed and maintained animals for intelligence and military purposes. These have included transportation, carrying loads, delivering messages, guarding military bases and clearing the areas around them. The list is extensive and includes, among other animals, carrier pigeons, camels, horses, donkeys, mules, dogs, and antelopes. That, however, is not what this article is about.

To carry out the particular project at the center of this article, several members of an elite unit were tasked with procuring equipment through a variety of channels. Among them were H. and G. and other soldiers from the same unit. They discovered that N., the project commander, who was on the verge of retiring from the IDF, was mixing the project’s activities with his private business dealings, which he was attempting to conduct with contacts who supplied him with equipment.

From its inception, the project was plagued by administrative and financial irregularities and operated with virtually no oversight.

“I was young and naive, and I genuinely believed in the importance of the project and its contribution to the country,” says H., one of its earliest participants, who later became a lawyer after leaving the defense establishment. “Everything was conducted based on trust. We were not even asked to sign a confidentiality agreement. But it soon became clear to me that the operation was being run negligently, and the oversight authorities began to raise suspicions.”

According to H., “The problems and slapdash management continued. Later, when I saw what was going on in the project, I came to my senses. Together with G., my colleague on the team, I exposed acts of corruption by the officer who ran the project on behalf of the defense establishment. While working on the project, the officer began cultivating outside contacts, beyond the IDF, and conducting private business with external contractors.

“When we went to complain and report this, including to very senior commanders in the defense establishment and to the Defense Establishment Comptroller, we were silenced. Instead of investigating the corruption allegations, they investigated us and accused us falsely of leaking secrets and making false allegations against the commander. We were subsequently fired in retaliation.”

The affair eventually reached the desk of Defense Minister and Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, who imposed a secrecy order on it, further deepening the veil of secrecy surrounding the project.

H. and G., driven by a sense of mission and a determination to root out corruption in such a prestigious and secretive project, were undeterred by the full force of the defense establishment brought to bear against them. Despite the obstacles placed in their path, they launched a public and legal campaign. After eight years of legal proceedings, their names were cleared and they received substantial compensation. Even then, however, the defense establishment continued to keep the affair under wraps.

Despite the drama unfolding behind the scenes, itself shrouded in secrecy, the project continued as usual. Before long, however, it became clear that it served no real purpose. Apart from a handful of isolated cases, the animals were almost never assigned specific operational missions.

On numerous occasions, senior defense officials were brought in to watch demonstrations of the specialized unit’s capabilities - almost as a form of entertainment.

“These were visits like going to the circus. We were the clowns putting on the show,” H., the lawyer, says.

Over the years, some of the most senior commanders in the defense establishment came to believe that the unit, in its existing form, served no useful purpose. Others argued that the project’s existence should instead be made public, on the grounds that doing so might help deter Israel’s enemies.

Several years ago, a decision was made to scale back the project, with a view to eventually shutting it down. But that never happened. And so, for years, those running the unusual animal project - military personnel and civilians alike - continued to maintain the project and its staff, spending public money all the while at the taxpayers’ expense.

“My estimate,” H. adds, “is that the project has cost around one billion shekels since it was established.” All of this, as noted, took place under an unprecedented- and, in my view, unjustified -veil of secrecy, maintained under the pretext of information security and the protection of state secrets.

Moreover, the project continued amid attempts to evade accountability and a campaign of cover-ups and false statements by the defense establishment, including statements made to the courts, which have by now become collaborators with the security system.

It is regrettable that the military censor, whose role is to balance security needs against democratic values, freedom of the press and the public’s right to know, has become a protective wall for a defense establishment that shields corrupt officials and suppresses publication for fear that its own disgrace will be exposed.